gongxiangp2/design-qa.md

Findings

• No actionable P0/P1/P2 issues remain for the current Stitch alignment pass.

Source Visual Truth

• Personal desktop: D:\AI Code\gongxiangp2\文件\stitch_\stitch_\_7\screen.png
• Public desktop: D:\AI Code\gongxiangp2\文件\stitch_\stitch_\_1\screen.png
• Create desktop: D:\AI Code\gongxiangp2\文件\stitch_\stitch_\_2\screen.png
• Personal mobile: D:\AI Code\gongxiangp2\文件\stitch_\stitch_\_10\screen.png
• Public mobile: D:\AI Code\gongxiangp2\文件\stitch_\stitch_\_11\screen.png

Implementation Screenshots

• Personal desktop: D:\AI Code\gongxiangp2\outputs\performance-survey-stitch-qa\personal-desktop.png
• Public desktop: D:\AI Code\gongxiangp2\outputs\performance-survey-stitch-qa\public-desktop.png
• Create desktop: D:\AI Code\gongxiangp2\outputs\performance-survey-stitch-qa\manage-desktop.png
• Personal mobile: D:\AI Code\gongxiangp2\outputs\performance-survey-stitch-qa\personal-mobile.png
• Public mobile: D:\AI Code\gongxiangp2\outputs\performance-survey-stitch-qa\public-mobile.png
• Create mobile: D:\AI Code\gongxiangp2\outputs\performance-survey-stitch-qa\manage-mobile.png

Viewport And State

• Desktop: 1280 x 720, routes tab=personal, tab=public, tab=manage.
• Mobile: 430 x 900, routes tab=personal, tab=public, tab=manage.
• Data state: local authenticated state with the currently available local data; empty ledgers are expected where the local dataset has no rows.

Full-View Comparison Evidence

• Header/nav: dashboard pages now use one unified material-platform dark app bar with left avatar/title, centered tabs on desktop, and right brand text. The previous personal/public/create color split has been removed per the latest product direction.
• Layout: dashboard content is constrained to 1200px on desktop, matching the Stitch public/create composition and avoiding edge-to-edge content at common desktop widths.
• Tables/cards: monthly ledger and public ledger use flat bordered tables/cards with minimal blue score emphasis. Empty states are flat dashed containers.
• Forms: create page uses the two-zone Stitch structure: month/template on the left, assessed people/evaluators/department on the right. Inputs, selects, search dropdowns, and selected chips use white fill and thin borders.
• Mobile: mobile pages no longer show purple background, duplicate header elements, or old workflow stat cards.

Focused Region Comparison

• Header region: compared against _7, _1, and _2; active tab and brand placement follow Stitch, while color mode is intentionally unified to the native material-platform dark bar.
• Filter/form controls: compared against _1 and _2; controls use thin borders, square/low-radius shape, and restrained blue focus/active states.
• Mobile top and bottom navigation: compared against _10 and _11; app-level navigation is simplified and no longer conflicts with content.

Patches Made Since Previous QA Pass

• Removed the global platform header from /performance-survey dashboard pages.
• Moved dashboard navigation into a unified dark top app bar.
• Reworked dashboard containers to a 1200px white, low-noise layout.
• Restyled public filters, employee search, department tree, selected chips, and score detail drawer.
• Restyled create form to match the Stitch two-column composition.
• Removed noisy mobile identity line and fake icon glyphs from bottom navigation.
• Removed the earlier white desktop header branch for public/create states.

Open Questions

• Current local data is sparse/empty, so row-rich table states were verified structurally rather than with dense production-like rows.

Implementation Checklist

• Header duplication removed.
• Personal, public, and create routes visually verified in desktop.
• Personal, public, and create routes visually verified in mobile.
• Page-specific controls remain interactive and data-backed.
• npm run lint -- --file "app/performance-survey/[[...path]]/page.tsx" passed.

Follow-up Polish

• If the team wants exact mobile icon parity, add a real icon font/library through the app asset pipeline instead of text glyphs or CSS icons.

final result: passed